Unfortunately, real life is complicated, and a party to a contract is sometimes forced to end the contract before it expires:
A lease agreement is a legal agreement that defines a binding relationship between a tenant and a landlord, for a fixed period set in advance. In most cases, both parties sign with a genuine intention to meet their obligations until the contract ends. But reality is not always simple – life circumstances change, unforeseen events may arise, and sometimes there is a need to end the arrangement earlier than planned.
When a party to the contract wants to end it before the date set in the contract:
The moment one of the parties asks to end the contract can create a feeling of uncertainty, tension or even conflict. For example: some tenants lose their source of income and are forced to leave the apartment before the end of the lease period, and some landlords need to vacate the property for personal use or because of an urgent need to sell the apartment.
Is It Permitted to Cancel a Lease Agreement Unilaterally?
When one party asks to cancel the contract unilaterally, without the consent of the other party, this is usually a breach of contract. In such a case, there may be legal consequences, such as a claim for damages or payment of rent until the end of the lease period. For example, a tenant who stops paying and leaves before the end of the lease period may be required by the landlord to pay the full amount remaining until the end of the lease period. On the other hand, if a landlord demands that the tenant leave early without justified cause, the landlord too risks a lawsuit and claims by the tenant.
Canceling a Lease Agreement by Consent – The Quiet Solution
To avoid legal battles, many understand that the best solution is to cancel a lease agreement by consent. This is a quiet, healthy and sensible way to end the contract, when both parties understand that there is no point in holding onto an agreement by force and prefer to dissolve the relationship in an agreed and respectful manner. In such a situation, the parties hold an open conversation, talk about the needs of each side, and together reach understandings regarding the terms of the ending: when the property will be vacated, whether an additional payment will be made, what will happen to the guarantee and the deposit, and whether there is an intention to find a replacement tenant.
Why Is It Important to Put the Agreement in Writing?
Even when both parties reach full agreement, it is very important that the process be documented in writing. It is not advisable to settle for oral promises, even when the relationship is good. A written agreement that details the terms of the ending, the dates and a declaration that the contract has ended with full understanding is the best way to ensure there are no misunderstandings later on. Such an agreement gives peace of mind, and allows each side to feel that they are acting properly and fairly.
Do Not Forget the Issue of the Deposit / Promissory Note:
Another issue that requires clear attention is the deposit. Tenants often ask themselves whether they will lose the deposit / promissory note if they end the agreement early. Here too, if the agreement to cancel the lease agreement is made by consent, it is possible to determine explicitly what will be done with the deposit or promissory note – whether they will be returned in full, whether some amount will be deducted from the deposit, whether the promissory note will be returned, or perhaps they will remain as backup until the move-out process is complete. When things are said in advance, openly and respectfully, it is easier to maintain a healthy relationship even after the engagement ends, and for both sides to feel secure.
Examples from case law:
1. An obligation to pay rent for only 2 months out of 12, because of the tenant’s objective difficulty in renting the leased premises – In Civil Case (Tel Aviv) 47739-09-17, a case was heard in which the tenant left the premises before the end of the lease period. The court ruled that the landlord has the right to demand payment of rent for the entire lease period even where the tenant asks to leave the premises before the end of the lease period. Actual period of use and remaining period: The tenant used the premises for only one month, while the original lease period was 12 months. The amounts awarded: The court ordered the tenant to pay:
- Rent for two additional months (September-October 2017) in the amount of NIS 8,190
- Agreed damages in the amount of NIS 20,000
- Municipal property tax (arnona) payment in the amount of NIS 4,924.83
It is important to note that the court emphasized that in an ordinary case the tenant could have been charged the full rent, but in this case the departure resulted from an objective difficulty in operating the business due to construction work that began in the building, and therefore the charge was reduced.
2. Premises not fit for use – giving rise to grounds for compensation for the tenant –
- Civil Case (Tel Aviv) 48868-09-14 Asaf Zeevi v. Genia Goldshmid The court ruled that the landlord breached the lease agreement because the premises were not fit for use due to plumbing problems. The landlord was ordered to return to the tenants the sum of NIS 33,000 in rent paid, and also to return the security check. In addition, the landlord was ordered to pay: NIS 1,200 for moving the apartment’s contents, NIS 700 for cleaning the premises, a broker’s fee for finding an alternative apartment, and NIS 5,000 in compensation for emotional distress.
- In Civil Case (Tel Aviv) 46094-02-20– Litan Weinberg v. Hagit Bracha The court rejected the landlord’s claims for compensation for breach of the agreement because the landlord did not repair material defects in the apartment after receiving a first warning letter. Of a rent debt of NIS 16,800, the tenant will be charged only half for loss of enjoyment (NIS 8,400), from which NIS 5,000 in legal costs must be deducted in the tenant’s favor, so the tenant must pay only NIS 3,400 of the NIS 16,800 in rent she should have paid.
3. Non-payment of rent as grounds for eviction from the premises –
- Civil Case (Nazareth) 7295-08-20 Wertzberger v. Alfasi – the tenant must pay 4 months’ rent, vacate the premises, and pay court costs and attorney’s fees totaling NIS 6,000.
When Is It Worth Contacting an Attorney?
There are cases in which it is not possible to reach agreement, or one of the parties is afraid to act without professional guidance. When there is a dispute, when there is uncertainty about the rights owed, or when there is concern about legal consequences, it is recommended to involve an attorney with experience in contract law or real estate. The attorney can review the existing agreement, assess whether there are legal grounds for unilateral cancellation, and draft a lease cancellation document that protects the interests of the party asking to leave the agreement.

