What Is the Difference Between Land Appreciation Tax (Mas Shevach) and Betterment Levy?

It is important to understand that the tax liability when selling a property is divided between the state and the municipality. Land Appreciation Tax (Mas Shevach) is paid to the Tax Authority (Land Taxation) on the profit from the sale, while betterment levy is paid to the local committee because of building rights that were added to the property after the date the seller acquired the rights. In this article we will expand on the difference between Land Appreciation Tax and betterment levy. 

What Is Betterment Levy?

This is a payment to the local planning and building committee due to an increase in the property’s value. Legally, the charge arises the moment the committee approves a new zoning plan (TABA) that grants variances or approves a non-conforming use that improves the property’s value. For example: 

Example of added building rights – additional construction

For example, a house with 4 rooms, for which the local authority gave approval to build an additional new room. The addition of the room raises the value of the property and triggers betterment levy.

Example of non-conforming use – from residential to business

Imagine you have a ground-floor apartment registered in the Land Registry (Tabu) as a residential property, but its location is suited to a clinic or law office. Therefore, you submit an application for a non-conforming use in order to change its designation to commercial. Since the value of a commercial property is usually higher than that of a residential apartment, the committee’s approval improved the property’s value without you having built even one wall. 

How Is Betterment Levy Calculated?

The value of the property before the improvement and the value of the property after the improvement must be calculated. The local authority collects 50% of the improvement.

For example:

An apartment to which the local authority permitted adding a 15 sq. m. room.

Value per sq. m.: NIS 35,000, amount of improvement NIS 525,000 (= NIS 35,000 per sq. m. * 15 sq. m.).

The betterment levy to be paid: NIS 262,500 (= NIS 525,000 * 50%).

Is the Amount of Betterment Levy Related to the Price at Which the Seller Sold the Property?

No. An appraiser examines what the value of the improvement is and calculates it. If the sale price is higher or lower than the property’s true value, this does not change the amount of the betterment levy.

When Is Betterment Levy Paid?

The moment you choose to realize the rights you received, which occurs in one of the following three cases and under the Third Schedule to the Planning and Building Law, 5725-1965, in the definition of the term “realization of rights”: 

  • Upon sale of the property and the transfer of rights to the buyers, 
  • The moment you receive a building permit in order to realize the new plan. 
  • Actual commencement of use, as first permitted due to the approval of the plan following which betterment levy applies.

In effect, the municipality allows deferring the payment until the moment you actually enjoy the improvement of the property. Whether by receiving payment or by upgrading the existing structure.

Exemption from Betterment Levy 

There are several cases in the law that grant an exemption from betterment levy, such as an exemption granted:

  • For construction or expansion of an apartment up to a total area of 140 sq. m., provided that the owner or a relative of the owner lives in it for at least four years from the time construction was completed, Section 9(c)(1) of the Planning and Building Law, 5725-1965.
  • For properties located in neighborhoods that are part of a neighborhood rehabilitation project that encourages development and renewal in these areas, Section 9(b)(1) of the Planning and Building Law, 5725-1965.
  • For educational, religious, welfare, health or sports institutions, as long as there is no business activity in them, Section 9(b)(4) of the Planning and Building Law, 5725-1965.

What Is Land Appreciation Tax?

A state tax imposed on the “appreciation” – that is, on the positive difference between the price at which you bought the property in the past and the price at which you sold it. The state sees this profit as a kind of real income, and therefore levies tax on it at a rate of 25% of the net profit – that is, after deducting expenses and linkage to the index. This tax applies only upon sale, and is intended to ensure that the state shares in the profits accumulated in the property.

Who Pays Land Appreciation Tax – the Buyer or the Seller?

The seller. The logic behind this is that the seller is the one who benefits from the profit generated in the transaction, and therefore must pay the tax to the state. In addition, the seller is required to settle the Land Appreciation Tax in order to obtain the approvals required for transferring ownership in the Land Registry to the buyer’s name.

How Is Land Appreciation Tax Calculated?

The original purchase price (linked to the Consumer Price Index) is subtracted from the current sale price, and the result is the “appreciation” on which you will pay the tax. The good news is that it can be reduced significantly by deducting recognized expenses (Section 39 of the Land Taxation Law (Appreciation and Purchase), 5723-1963), such as:

  1. Fees of a real estate attorney, 
  2. Brokerage fees 
  3. Purchase Tax paid when buying the property in the past
  4. The costs of renovations or repairs that were made
  5. Payment of betterment levy to the municipality
  6. Real interest on a mortgage.

When Is Land Appreciation Tax Paid?

By law, you must report the sale of a property to the Tax Authority within 30 days of signing the contract, and payment must be made within 60 days. Meeting the deadlines is critical to avoid fines and interest. The Land Appreciation Tax approval is important so that you can receive approval for the transfer of an apartment in the Land Registry.

Important – Payment of Tax by Way of an Advance Payment:

Under Section 15 of the Land Taxation Law (Appreciation and Purchase), 5723-1963, the buyer may not transfer more than 40% of the amount of the consideration, except after the buyer has paid the Land Taxation office the Land Appreciation Tax advance payment. 

The Land Appreciation Tax advance payment is 15% of the transaction amount – for transactions in which the seller purchased before 7.11.2001, and 7% for transactions in which the seller purchased after 7.11.2001.

To pay a Land Appreciation Tax advance payment, an application must be submitted to Land Taxation to approve the amount of the advance payment, and after approval it will be possible to pay using the payment voucher.

It is also possible to reduce the amount of the advance payment, under Section 15(e)(1) of the Land Taxation Law. Land Taxation must respond to a request to reduce the advance payment within 20 days, and if it does not respond, it will be deemed to have agreed to the request for reduction.

After the tax is paid through the advance payment, a Land Appreciation Tax approval can be issued, and thus the buyer is protected from situations in which the seller is still in discussions with Land Taxation regarding the amount of Land Appreciation Tax the seller must pay.

Who Is Entitled to a Land Appreciation Tax Refund?

It is possible to conduct a retroactive eligibility check and receive a Land Appreciation Tax refund in cases where the tax calculation was flawed. Eligibility for a refund usually stems from the following factors:

  1. Spreading the profit from the sale over a period of up to four years back, which can lower the tax bracket according to the sellers’ income.
  2. Using tax credit points, taking into account marital status or reaching retirement age (over 60).
  3. The ability to offset other capital losses (such as from the stock exchange) against the profit generated from the sale of the property.

What Is the Difference Between Land Appreciation Tax and Betterment Levy?

The difference is in three things: 

  1.  Land Appreciation Tax is paid to the Tax Authority while betterment levy is paid to the local committee (the municipality)
  2. Land Appreciation Tax is generally 25% of the net real profit, while betterment levy collects 50% from the owner.
  3. Land Appreciation Tax is on the financial profit you made from the sale; betterment levy is for the right that the municipality gave you to improve the property’s value.

 

In summary, 

Professional guidance from a real estate attorney will ensure that you do not pay unnecessary tax. Accurate advice will allow you to plan the transaction wisely, save money and ensure that the sale process goes smoothly. We would be happy to assist you with any question, real estate attorney, Limor Galanti-Yerushalmi. 

Interested in a consultation?

We would be happy to help you with any question

More Articles