Dissolution of co-ownership in an inheritance is intended to enable you to derive economic value from your proportional share of the inheritance, whether through division of the property or through its sale. It is important to know that this is a right anchored in the inheritance and land laws, which ensures that no one can force a person to remain in a partnership against his will.
The Succession Law vs. the Land Law
When a dissolution of co-ownership proceeding is begun, it is worth getting to know in depth the difference between the Land Law, which provides that “any co-owner of jointly owned real estate is entitled at any time to demand dissolution of the co-ownership,” and the Succession Law, which seeks to regulate the division of the estate fairly among heirs. While the Land Law provides the technical tools for carrying out the sale or division, the Succession Law gives the Family Court tools that require it to take into account a will or family circumstances. The tension between these two laws requires a delicate balance between your property right in the asset and specific provisions of law, such as granting a priority right to a particular heir.
Dissolution of Co-Ownership of Real Estate Between Siblings
Dissolution of co-ownership of real estate between siblings requires thoughtful navigation between the dry provisions of the law and the emotional baggage that naturally accompanies this process.
The Emotional Complexity
Dissolution of co-ownership between siblings is not like a business dissolution, since it often stirs up old grievances and long-standing feelings of being treated unfairly. You must act sensitively, as overly forceful decisions may lead to estrangement, and therefore you should consider mediation before turning to the courts. Properly managing this dynamic will allow you to preserve the unity of the family while ensuring that each of you receives what is due to him.
Section 113 of the Succession Law – Priority for Heirs in Purchasing the Property
When one of you wishes to keep the property in his ownership, it is worth getting to know Section 113 of the Succession Law, which gives an heir priority in purchasing the other siblings’ shares before the property goes on the market for sale. You should know that if there is a dispute over the price, the court will appoint an appraiser who will assess the real market value. This right is a powerful legal tool that balances the desire of some of the heirs to cash out with the desire of others to preserve the property.
Reasonable Usage Fees – What to Do If One of the Siblings Lives in the Property?
In situations in which one of you lives in the property and thereby also prevents its sale, case law is on your side in allowing you to demand “reasonable usage fees,” which are proportional rent for your share in the property. You should make clear to the sibling who lives there that his mere possession of the property does not give him the right to prevent the dissolution, and that he must bear the economic costs for as long as he is the only one using the joint property.
Examples from Case Law
Here are several examples of judgments and key legal principles, which illustrate how the courts apply the principles of dissolution of co-ownership in practice.
The Five Siblings Dispute
Five siblings inherited a real estate property that could not be divided among all of them. One of the siblings asked to sell the property on the open market, while the others wanted to buy his share and keep the property. The Family Court ruled that under Section 113 of the Succession Law, priority should be given to heirs who wish to purchase the property over its sale to a third party, by means of an internal pricing mechanism among the heirs according to a market value determined by an appraiser.
Bad Faith in a Demand for Dissolution – Leave to Appeal (Civil) 6339/97
The landmark Supreme Court judgment Roker v. Salomon dealt with the tension between the property right and the duty of good faith. Although it did not deal with an inheritance but with a neighbor dispute in a condominium, it is the legal source for the principle that the right to demand dissolution of co-ownership is not absolute and may be limited if it is exercised in extreme bad faith.
Reasonable Usage Fees Between Siblings – Family Court Case 1890-07
In a lawsuit between siblings concerning a shop of about 27 sq. m. located in a building that also includes residential apartments, the rights in which were granted to them by their parents who passed away. The plaintiffs demanded compensation in the amount of 38,000 NIS for lost rent, claiming that one of the siblings holds the property and uses it exclusively. The court examined the rights in the property, which include irrevocable instructions and the wills of the parents. The judgment emphasizes that in situations in which one co-owner makes exclusive use of the jointly owned property, the other co-owners have the right to demand reasonable payment for their share.
Dissolution of Co-Ownership Without Consent
When a situation arises in which one of the heirs refuses to cooperate with the division of the estate, the law allows suing for dissolution of co-ownership. In this proceeding, the court has the authority to force the end of the co-ownership against the wishes of the refusing party by appointing a receiver whose role is to manage the sale of the property to the highest bidder. The receiver is responsible for:
- Publishing a tender,
- Conducting the bidding
- Transferring the monetary proceeds
Important to know: Although this forced proceeding accelerates the process, it also involves costs for the receiver’s fees and other legal expenses. Therefore it is recommended to use it as a last resort.
Can Dissolution of Co-Ownership Be Forced?
Yes. The law views forced co-ownership as an undesirable situation, and therefore grants the absolute right to demand dissolution of co-ownership “at any time.” This right makes it possible to force the end of the co-ownership even if the other heirs object, based on the view that freedom of property action overrides the wishes of the majority. However, it is worth knowing that there are exceptions in which the court will halt the dissolution, especially if it is proven that the party seeking dissolution acted in extreme bad faith.
How Is Dissolution of Co-Ownership Carried Out?
Dissolution of co-ownership can be carried out in several ways, with the law’s preference always being for division in kind. If it is a residential building, the preferred route is to register it as a condominium. However, if the property cannot be divided for planning reasons, such as a small apartment, the court will order a public auction to the highest bidder and division of the money among you. You should understand that while division in kind preserves the property, a public auction is usually faster.
How Long Does Dissolution of Co-Ownership of Real Estate Take?
The time it takes to dissolve co-ownership varies dramatically depending on the level of agreement between you. A proceeding consisting only of an estate division agreement may end within a few months, but turning to the legal track may drag on for years. You must take into account delaying factors such as:
- Appointing an appraiser to assess the value of the property,
- Complex bidding procedures
- Land taxation
- Filing appeals against interim decisions
- Heirs’ objections to the identity of the receiver
Understanding the timelines in advance will help you manage your expectations and consider whether an early compromise is preferable to conducting a long and expensive process in court.
In summary,
Dissolution of co-ownership in an inheritance carries not only legal and emotional challenges, but also heavy tax implications that may take a significant share of the property’s value. Therefore, before tempers rise, it is recommended to consult an attorney who also specializes in family law. We would be happy to assist you with any question.

