The process of dissolving a co-ownership is meant to allow every co-owner to realize his or her right in the property. The Land Law prefers “division in kind of land,” that is, dividing the assets among the owners rather than a forced sale. In this article we will discuss what division in kind is, what happens when the owners do not agree, and examine the average time this process takes.
Division in Kind of Land – Definition
Division in kind means a de facto split of the jointly owned assets into separate units, so that each co-owner becomes the sole owner in proportion to his or her relative share in the original property. For example, if two co-owners hold a plot of land, dissolving the co-ownership of the land by division in kind will result in the registration of two separate plots in the Land Registry (Tabu), one for each co-owner. For the court to approve division in kind, it must be proven that the following are met:
Physical characteristics
The property must have physical characteristics that allow it to be split, such as sufficient size, a shape that allows equal division, and the absence of topographical or structural conditions that prevent a reasonable separation. Usually, a land appraiser is required to examine the properties and give his or her opinion.
Planning feasibility
The division must comply with the planning and building laws. Approval of the planning authorities is required, confirming that the new parcels meet the requirements of the local and national outline plans, for example, a minimum plot size. Each new unit must be an independent property unit that can be registered in the Land Registry (Tabu).
Equalization payments
In many cases, even if a physical division is possible, gaps in value arise between the parcels, for example because one parcel has a more attractive location than the other, building rights, and so on. The equalization payment mechanism allows the court to order a co-owner who received a parcel of higher value to pay the co-owner who received a parcel of lower value.
When Will the Court Not Choose This Preferred Option?
The rule of preference for division in kind is so strong that the court will depart from it only in an extreme case, as Section 40 of the Land Law provides that the court will order the sale of land only if it is proven that:
“In land that cannot be divided, and likewise if the court is satisfied that division in kind will cause substantial loss to the co-owners, all or some of them, the dissolution of the co-ownership shall be by way of a sale of the land and a division of the proceeds.”
The burden of proving what is considered a “substantial loss” lies on the party arguing for dissolution by sale. The case law has held that a minor loss is not enough, and that what is required is an economic loss that affects the value of the property. That is, if division in kind makes the property unusable or drastically reduces its value, only then will the court decide on its sale.
Can a Dissolution of Co-Ownership Be Forced?
Yes. And this is a cornerstone of property law in Israel. The right to demand the dissolution of a co-ownership is an almost absolute right, and it is anchored in Section 37(a) of the Land Law, which provides that: “Every co-owner of jointly owned land is entitled at any time to demand the dissolution of the co-ownership.” The guiding principle is that a person should not be forced to remain in a shared property relationship if he or she does not wish to. This right is regarded as a fundamental property right, and it is not conditioned on the consent of the other co-owners or on any reason for the demand for dissolution. Even if most of the co-owners want the co-ownership to continue, the wish of a single co-owner, even one with a small share, is enough to compel dissolution of the co-ownership.
How Long Does Dissolving a Co-Ownership of Land by Division in Kind Take?
The time required to complete a co-ownership dissolution by way of division in kind is affected by the cooperation between the parties and by the complexity of the legal and planning file. While dissolution proceedings by agreement may take about 6 months, a forced dissolution proceeding, which includes the appointment of a receiver, takes on average about two years, and in complex cases even longer.
The Preference for Division in Kind – From the Case Law: LCA 8233/08 Kovshi v. Awad
This judgment is a milestone in strengthening the principle, because the Supreme Court repeated and emphasized that the preference for division in kind is almost absolute. It clarified that selling a jointly owned property as a means of dissolving a co-ownership is only the second option, and that the court must use it only when there is a clear obstacle to division in kind.
In summary,
Seeking early legal advice is critical for a co-ownership dissolution proceeding. A real estate attorney will examine the planning and economic data in order to determine the most appropriate way to dissolve the co-ownership, division in kind or sale. This advice makes it possible to build a focused strategy, prepare the required expert opinions, and reduce the risks involved in a lengthy court proceeding. We would be happy to help with any question.

