What Is Dissolution of Co-Ownership in Real Estate?

Dissolution of co-ownership (partition) of real estate is a legal proceeding that allows holders of joint rights in a real estate property (such as an apartment, a private house, a lot, or agricultural land) to bring the co-ownership of the real estate to an end.

The dissolution proceeding is an important solution for a situation in which disputes or conflicts arise between co-owners of real estate. This occurs, for example, when heirs jointly received real estate and disputes arise between them.

Legal framework:

Section 37(a) of the Land Law, 5729-1969: “Any co-owner of jointly owned real estate is entitled at any time to demand dissolution of the co-ownership”

Ways to Dissolve Co-Ownership of Real Estate:

Dissolution of co-ownership can be carried out in several ways, depending on the characteristics of the property and the wishes of the parties:

  1. Dissolution by agreement, or by court order (Section 38):
    • In many cases, the co-owners reach mutual agreements regarding how the property will be divided or sold. The property can be physically divided (division in kind), so that each party receives a specific portion, or the property can be sold and the proceeds divided among them.
    • Section 38(a) of the Law – dissolution by agreement: “Dissolution of the co-ownership shall be in accordance with an agreement between the co-owners; if the agreement provides for division of the real estate in kind, the agreement requires the approval of the Supervisor confirming that the division conforms to the provisions of the Planning and Building Law and any other enactment on the matter.”
    • Section 38(b) of the Law – dissolution by the court: “In the absence of an agreement as stated in subsection (a), dissolution of the co-ownership shall be by court order.”
  2. Dissolution through division in kind (Section 39) :
    • If the property is land or a lot that can be divided into independent parcels, a lawsuit for physical division can be filed, and a separate registration made for each parcel at the Land Registry Office (Tabu). However, division in kind depends on the practical and legal ability to carry it out, including in accordance with zoning plans and economic feasibility.
    • For example: co-owners of real estate who share the same lot, on which there are two houses. In such a situation, each co-owner will receive a house and two new sub-parcels will be registered, provided that the division complies with the Planning and Building Law and any other applicable enactment.
    • Section 39(a) of the Land Law: “ Where real estate is divisible, the co-ownership shall be dissolved by division in kind”.
    • Section 39(b) of the Land Law: “Where division in kind is possible only if equalization payments are paid by one co-owner to another, the court may obligate them to make such payments, if it seems to it efficient and just in the circumstances of the matter” – where, as a result of the division, equalization payments must be made, the court has the authority to obligate the co-owners to pay them.
    • Section 42(a): “Where the main part of the jointly owned real estate is a building suitable for registration as a condominium, the court may, after receiving the opinion of the Supervisor, order dissolution of the co-ownership by registering the building in the condominium register and allocating apartments to the co-owners according to their shares – When real estate is divided in kind, a condominium can be registered, and each co-owner will then be an independent owner of a separate sub-parcel of his own (provided that a condominium can be registered).

 

  1. Dissolution through sale (Section 40):
    • When division in kind is not possible (for example: two spouses who are co-owners of a residential apartment, since the apartment cannot be divided in two), the solution is to sell the property – either to a third party, or one of the co-owners buys the other co-owner’s share.
    • If the parties are unable to reach an agreement, a request can be made to the court to appoint a receiver for the purpose of selling the property. The receiver may advertise the property, negotiate with buyers, and divide the proceeds after covering expenses.
    • Section 40(a) of the Law: ” Where real estate is not divisible, and also where the court is satisfied that division in kind would cause considerable loss to the co-owners, all or some of them, the co-ownership shall be dissolved by sale of the real estate and division of the proceeds.”
    • Section 40(b) of the Law: The sale shall be conducted in the manner of the sale of attached real estate in the Execution Office: “The sale shall be conducted in the manner in which attached real estate is sold in the Execution Office, unless the court has ordered another manner that seems to it more efficient and just in the circumstances of the matter”.
    • In the case of dissolution of co-ownership of real estate owned by spouses: the court will not order dissolution unless the court is satisfied that the minor children and the spouse who has custody of them have a housing arrangement, Section 40A(a) of the Law: “ Where the court has decided under Section 40 to dissolve, by way of sale, the co-ownership of jointly owned real estate that is an apartment of spouses used by them for residence, it shall not order its execution and the sale shall be delayed, so long as the court is not satisfied that for the spouses’ minor children and for the spouse who has custody of them, together, another housing arrangement suitable for their needs has been found, including an interim arrangement for temporary housing suitable for their needs, for the period it shall determine”.

When some co-owners want to continue the co-ownership and others want to end it, what is the law and the rationale?

Legal framework:

  • Section 43 of the Law: “ The court will take into account, as far as possible, the demand of some of the co-owners to continue the co-ownership among them and the other wishes of co-owners”.
  • That is: the court must take both views into account: both the desire to continue the co-ownership and the desire to end it.

Case law: dissolution of real estate co-ownership is to be preferred over continuation of the co-ownership:

  • Leave to Appeal (Civil) 8233/08 Margalit Kovshi v. Attorney Eyal Schwartz (decided October 10, 2010) – “The right of the co-owners to continue and maintain the co-ownership relationship will be honored up to the point at which a co-owner expresses a sincere and good-faith wish to bring about its dissolution, at which point the co-owner’s desire for dissolution of the co-ownership joins the aim of moving the real estate market and preventing stagnation, and these will generally prevail over the wishes of the other co-owners and will justify dissolution of the co-ownership, even if an effort is made to continue and maintain the co-ownership relationship between the co-owners who desire it “

 

  • Civil Appeal 288/71 Mordechai v. Mordechai (decided January 27, 1972) “Section 43 of the Land Law is to be interpreted in the most restrictive manner. In his view, the legislator did not intend to give the other co-owners the ability to prevent the dissolution of the co-ownership, or even to postpone it, but only opened to them the option of giving the withdrawing co-owner his share, and leaving the rest of the co-ownership relationship in place”

 

Summary: It is clear from the case law that:

  1. A co-owner’s right to demand dissolution of the co-ownership overrides the wishes of the other co-owners to continue the co-ownership
  2. Section 43 is interpreted restrictively.
  3. The section is not intended to allow preventing dissolution of the co-ownership, but only to allow the remaining co-owners to continue the co-ownership among themselves while giving the withdrawing co-owner his share

This is provided that the request for dissolution of the co-ownership is made in good faith and does not constitute an abuse of right.

 

What is the rationale for preferring dissolution over co-ownership?

1.Preventing disputes and stagnation:

    • Civil Case (Hadera) 28066-10-21 Jamal Osman v. Hamad Abbas (decided November 26, 2023) “Section 37(a) of the Land Law establishes the right of every co-owner of real estate to demand, at will, dissolution of the co-ownership, and expresses the assumption that co-ownership of real estate is not a desirable state of affairs and that its termination should be encouraged”

2.Promoting development of real estate and the economy:

    • Civil Appeal 319/74 Rubinstein and Co. Contracting Company Ltd. v. Fine (decided November 27, 1975) “The legislative policy underlying this provision is not only that co-ownership of real estate may cause quarrels and disputes… but that dissolution of the co-ownership generally encourages the desirable trend of real estate development”

3.Promoting the marketability of assets:

    • Leave to Appeal (Civil) 8233/08 Kovshi v. Schwartz (decided October 10, 2010) “Co-ownership relationships carry within them ‘seeds of strife and contention’ whose resolution by the court is in doubt, as well as the negative potential inherent in co-ownership as something that delays the development of jointly owned assets, burdens the co-owners’ ability to make use of them, prevents the liquidity of assets and the constant movement in the real estate market, and complicates the execution of transactions in them”
  1. Protecting individual autonomy:
  • Civil Case (Tel Aviv) 69071-08-23 Sahar Lev v. Yuval Damol (decided January 28, 2025) “The above provisions of the law are a clear expression by the legislator that co-ownership relationships are to be brought to an end at the demand of a single co-owner alone. The court’s discretion in the matter is extremely limited”.

What is the law where there is a clause that prohibits dissolution of co-ownership?

  • Section 39(b) of the Land Law provides: “ Where a co-ownership agreement contained a condition that prohibits or limits the right to demand dissolution of the co-ownership for a period exceeding three years, the court may, after three years, order dissolution of the co-ownership, notwithstanding the condition, if it seems just to it in the circumstances of the matter”.
  • That is, where the co-ownership cannot be dissolved for a period exceeding 3 years, the court has the authority to order dissolution of the co-ownership if it sees that this is just under the circumstances.

The Importance of Legal Guidance in the Process of Dissolving Co-Ownership:

Dissolution of co-ownership is a legally complex and sometimes emotionally charged process – especially when it involves family members (for example, siblings who inherited a joint property), or former spouses. The guidance of an attorney experienced in real estate law ensures:

  • Protection of the rights of all parties.
  • Understanding of the various legal options.
  • Drafting of orderly legal agreements.
  • Dealing with objections or legal claims.
  • Comprehensive advice regarding tax implications (Land Appreciation Tax (Mas Shevach), Purchase Tax, and so on).
  • Handling registration of the property in the Land Registry (Tabu) after the dissolution.

The attorney knows how to represent the client against the other parties and before the court, and to make sure that the proceeding is conducted efficiently and leads to the best possible result.

When Is an Attorney Needed for Dissolution of Co-Ownership?

  • When one of the parties objects to the dissolution or creates difficulties.
  • When the property is complex (for example, a building with different units, or land with building rights).
  • When there are debts or attachments on the property.
  • When there are previous agreements that need to be interpreted or enforced.
  • When appointment of a receiver is required.
  • When dividing an inheritance that includes jointly owned real estate.

Summary:

Dissolution of co-ownership of real estate is a basic right granted to every co-owner of real estate, but the path to realizing it may be complex and requires professional guidance. Whether by agreed dissolution or through a lawsuit, it is important to understand the implications, the possible ways of dissolving the co-ownership, and the right way to ensure a fair and lawful outcome. Legal guidance from an attorney who specializes in real estate ensures protection of rights and makes it possible to end the co-ownership without falling into unnecessary disputes or costly mistakes. It is important to remember: the more professionally and precisely the proceeding is carried out, the smaller the economic and emotional harm to the parties involved. We would be happy to assist you with any question.

Interested in a consultation?

We would be happy to help you with any question

More Articles